top of page

Season 1: Joshua Guimond

Public·906 members

Hi everyone, I've been following this case loosely the last several years or so and have recently jumped back in following all the fantastic new focus and evidence (like this brilliant podcast - thank you for shedding light on Josh's case).

I watched the unsolved mysteries episode tonight and was wondering if you were going to dive into any more details around Josh's close friends, particularly Nick. I hate doing this, but after the episode I have to say something there definitely seems "off". I know he has been through a lot and maybe it's unfair to do this here, but the fact that he was into Katie, they (Josh and Nick) may have been arguing close to the time of his disappearance, he refused to take a polygraph (I know they are not very reliable but it was more so his explanation/reasoning that seemed off to me "not wanting a false positive"), and that there was a discrepancy in when Nick said he left Katie's that night vs what Katie said all is enough imo to warrant a further deep dive (which I'm guessing has already happened and we're just not privy to it).

I'm not sure if you plan to discuss different specific persons of interest (and whether or not he even is an official person of interest at this point in time!) but I wanted to throw that out there. I also was wondering if it's ever been confirmed/asked if Nick had a car on campus at the time of Josh's disappearance? Reason being one other individual in your discussion board recently talked about the bus schedules between campuses - if Nick did indeed leave Katie's at 2:30 like he said, he would've had to have drove as the busses were no longer running (they stopped at 2). If he didn't have a car, then that leans more toward Katie being accurate and/or there would be an opportunity to confirm Nick's timeline via a third party that gave him a ride. Like I said, I am sure they looked into this but just throwing it out there!

I look forward to further episodes and hearing more about additional leads!

Sonshine Tres
 Stacy Wolbeck
Sara Anne Hawkins
Unknown member
Oct 28, 2022

The other thing I could think of in terms of not wanting to do the polygraph - Maybe there is a legit discrepancy in the timeline when he left Katie's but it's for a completely different reason (not related to Josh) that for whatever reason he wouldn't want disclosed either. Definitely possible and could be why he'd not want to take the polygraph for fear of a 'false positive' that is misconstrued as having to do with Josh (when it wasn't). Like I said earlier, I don't think it means he's involved but it's not unfathomable with all of the factors that people would wonder, myself included is all.

FWIW I tend to lean more toward the chat/meet up gone wrong or shady people on campus (with all the sketch stuff going on so close to his disappearance anything is possible) - my intent with my posts was never to say Nick was involved but simply to raise those observations and questions.



This message board is for Simply Vanished podcast listeners ...
bottom of page