Just finished the Unsolved Mysteries episode, and one thing that stuck with me was the police talking about the suspicious Pontiac Sunfire being on campus during that time.
I googled the car and thought it looks a lot like the car Jeremy described in episode 4. (It was also mentioned in the next episode.)
Do others agree?
I looked up the car. Metallic orange was pretty common starting in 2001. However, I didn’t see any with a red interior and these cars came with a rear spoiler. Not a luggage rack. It doesn’t seem like a match